Non-Compete Analysis
Questionnaire
Try answering this
Question 1 of 5
Client
All 5 questions · 0 answered
Body
Non-Compete Analysis
Arrow keys or Space step through the document. Click a paragraph to highlight it.
Non-compete analysis memorandum
Client.
Employer.
Last day of employment. What is the Person's last day of employment?
Restraint. Which restraint does the agreement contain?
The Person's account. In the Person's own words, what does the covenant forbid, and what does the Employer say it protects?
Question presented
Whether the restraint the Employer's agreement imposes is enforceable against the Person under New York law, and what scope the Firm would accept.
Short answer
Reserved for the reviewing lawyer. The analysis below supplies the basis.
The governing standard
New York enforces a restrictive covenant only when it is reasonable in time and area, necessary to protect a legitimate interest, and not a restraint of ordinary competition. BDO Seidman v. Hirshberg, 93 N.Y.2d 382 (1999). The Employer must show the restraint protects trade secrets, confidential customer information, or goodwill the Employer paid for. A covenant that bars the Person from any role in the field restrains competition; it does not protect a legitimate interest.
The factors
- Time. The period the restraint runs. New York accepts a longer term where the Person sold a business than where the Person left a job.
- Area and scope. The territory and the forbidden roles. A scope broader than the Person's actual territory or duties invites the court to narrow it.
- Legitimate interest. The specific asset the restraint protects. The Firm names it or treats the covenant as void.
- Hardship. The restraint must leave the Person a way to earn a living. A covenant that forecloses the Person's only trade is an undue hardship.
- Partial enforcement. New York courts may enforce a covenant to the extent it is reasonable and strike the rest. Columbia Ribbon & Carbon Manufacturing Co. v. A-1-A Corporation, 42 N.Y.2d 496 (1977).
Recommendation
Reserved for the reviewing lawyer. The deliverable severance_negotiation_letter__new_york carries the requested
changes to the Employer.